The day the fossil feathers flew

3D printing

Media playback is unsupported on your device

Media captionModern scanning techniques show Archaeopteryx is no fake

There is no greater insult you can hurl at a museum than to suggest its prize fossil is a fake.

But that’s what the esteemed astronomer Sir Fred Hoyle did in 1985 when he doubted the authenticity of arguably the most priceless possession in the collections of what is now London’s Natural History Museum (NHM). All hell broke loose as the claim made headlines around the world.

Recommended For You

WP VidXPress PRO

the PRO upgrade adds insanely powerful features to WP VidXpress!

The fossil was Archaeopteryx – the seminal discovery made in a German quarry just a couple of years after Darwin published his theory of evolution.

Archaeopteryx’ significance is that it demonstrates birds are likely descended from dinosaurs.

The 147-million-year-old fossil is split across two slabs of rock – what experts call a “part and counterpart”. Flip your eyes back and forth between the pair and you’ll see an extraordinary mix of features – with the teeth, tail and hands of a reptile; but with a wishbone, feet and a spectacular spread of feathers that just scream “bird”.

And it was those feathers that Sir Fred couldn’t accept.

Amy Scott-Murray
Image caption An astronomical claim: The museum simply could not ignore Sir Fred

He imaged them with an SLR camera from all angles and announced, in the Journal of Photography, that they were probably deliberate impressions made in some kind of limestone cement that had been added on top of a true dinosaur specimen.

Recommended For You

Elite eCom Masterclass Done For You Pack

Jump start your Elite eCom Masterclass earnings with our done for you pack and case studies!

Desktop Mailer Unlimited

Desktop Email - send campaigns and newsletters from your desktop - Unlimited

The museum took great umbrage and responded with a detailed analysis in the journal Science. It had to.

Sir Fred was high-profile and if the idea of fakery in a transitional fossil went unchallenged, Archaeopteryx would quickly become a cause célèbre for the anti-evolution movement. And don’t forget, the museum was the scene of perhaps the biggest fossil fake of all time – Piltdown Man.

The astronomer’s accusation could not be allowed to pass.

dental rubber

Media playback is unsupported on your device

Media captionLorraine Cornish: “Archaeopteryx is one of our most iconic specimens”

The “evidence” of forgery was actually pretty easy to unpick. Microscopic investigations showed that hairline cracks in the feathers, invisible in the SLR images, could be matched up on the part and counterpart. Likewise, the branching of manganese crystals running through the rock.

But there was one test the NHM couldn’t do properly back then which it can do today. And that is to bring the two halves of the fossil back together to show they are a perfect fit.

Fred Hoyle Image copyright Trustees of the NHM, London
Image caption Dr Scott-Murray’s department is now busily scanning the NHM’s collections

The addition of a fake limestone base for the feather impressions should make that impossible because it would have changed the shape of the slabs. The museum certainly had a go back in the late 80s using carefully made casts, but these cannot replicate the precision of modern digital techniques. And so it was during recent conservation work that the two halves of Archaeopteryx were put in a laser scanner.

Recommended For You

CreateDeliver - Membership Platform (One time license)

CreateDeliver Membership Site Creation Platform. One Time Special Offer Charter License.

Flexy Agency Rights ( Yearly )

Flexy App Fe, Lifetime License (Unlimited Projects)

One Time Hosting Triple Up Copper 3

Upgrade your One Time Hosting Copper 1 Plan to Copper 3 Plan includes hosting for 3 websites with 3 GB storage. (Note: this is an upgrade to the One Time Hosting Copper 1 Plan - this is not a standalone product)

Lo and behold, the virtual part and counterpart seamlessly go together at a scale that can be measured in microns (thousandths of a millimetre).

“We’ve colour-coded the scan and where it’s green, there’s essentially no gap between the part and counterpart,” explained Dr Amy Scott-Murray from the NHM’s Imaging and Analysis Centre.

“A lot of it is blue, showing a positive gap of a few millimetres, and that’s where conservators have excavated the limestone to better show the bones. But as you can see, most areas are a perfect match,” she told me.

Hintze Hall

Media playback is unsupported on your device

Media captionDr Amy Scott-Murray: “It’s a powerful technique that allows us to make digital surrogates”

The museum acquired its scanning equipment when it decided to move its blue whale skeleton into the main entrance hall, in place of “Dippy” the diplodocus.

All the cetacean’s bones were cleaned and had digital copies made of them before being re-hung in the new location.

Thousands of specimens at the NHM will ultimately go through the same process.

Imaging and Analysis Centre Image copyright Imaging and Analysis Centre, NHM
Image caption Can you see the head and tentacles? A 95-million-year-old fossil octopus, Keuppia sp.

Lorraine Cornish, the NHM’s current head of conservation, had not long joined the museum when the Archaeopteryx row flared up. It was her job to make the copies for the rebuttal analysis using dental rubber and resin.

“Back in the day, I was always making casts of the likes of Archaeopteryx for other museums and institutions,” she said. “But today, with this amazing technology and 3D printing – we can make copies that are three times the size, or half the size; and we can even emphasise particular parts and print those off. All the while, we minimise the risk to the specimen because we get it out once, scan it and then just share the digital files.”

She added: “The part and counterpart of Archaeopteryx are very heavy, and elements of the fossil are very fragile. So, you could never really bring them together in the way we can with this new technique.

“I have a huge emotional attachment to this fossil. I remember how hurt and upset everyone was in the museum when the original claim of forgery was made, and the huge amount of work that went into refuting that claim. This laser scan is just one more piece in the puzzle that rejects what Sir Fred wrote about Archaeopteryx.”

Archaeopteryx lithographica is arguably the most valuable fossil in the NHM’s collections. It can be viewed in the Treasures Gallery above Hintze Hall, the location of the blue whale.

Original Article : HERE ; This post was curated & posted using : RealSpecific

Thank you for taking the time to read our article.

If you enjoyed our content, we'd really appreciate some "love" with a share or two.

And ... Don't forget to have fun!

Recommended Products

Motion Mascots V2 - X3 Profit-Booster Elite Upgrade

Ultimate Collection of 1300+ "Best-Of-The-Best" Graphic Templates! Must-Have Toolkit For Serious Marketers!

Video Ad Rival - Pro Plus Pack

Grab 24 Ready to Use Video Ad Rival Templates + Matching Scripts With Your Special Customer Only Discount...


Annual Access and Updates For The Bloxy Site Builder, Plus 10 Templates

Leave a Reply